Vote by the Pint 4-Pack

$ 36.00 

  • Vote by the Pint 4-Pack
  • Vote by the Pint 4-Pack
  • Vote by the Pint 4-Pack

This product is currently sold out.


These two flavors emerged as the finalists from this year’s Flavor Frenzy. For a very limited time, we are offering the finalists online for nationwide shipping. Your order counts as a vote so choose wisely!

Please note:  This is a pre-order.  These specially made flavors will be ready to ship on April 3rd and 4th.  

The contenders:

  • Peanut Butter Munchies: peanut butter pretzel base with housemade munchies mix-in (pretzels, potato chips and Ritz crackers) and Reese’s pieces
  • Corn to Run: creamy corn ice cream with cornmeal crumble and blueberry swirls

Pre-order one of the below 4-Packs to cast your vote:

  • All-in for Peanut Butter Munchies (4 pints)
  • All-in for Corn to Run (4 pints)
  • Undecided (2 pints of each)

Bonus: every Vote by the Pint 4-Pack order will get an I Voted sticker, too!


Shipping Information

We are receiving a very high demand for our ice cream both in-store and for shipping nationwide. As a result, we need to limit the amount of ice cream that is sold online each day to ensure there is enough ice cream for everyone. The next available shipping day is preselected by default. You will receive your ice cream 1-2 days after your ship day, depending on shipping speed selected in checkout. You're welcome to choose a ship day in the future if desired.

Shipping Pledge

Everyone loves receiving the gift of ice cream at their doorstep but no one likes receiving melted ice cream. This is why we will happily reship your ice cream or issue you a full refund if it does not arrive perfect, delicious and frozen.