Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack

$ 36.00 

  • Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack
  • Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack
  • Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack
  • Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack
  • Choose Your Own Story 4-Pack

This variant is currently sold out


You’re invited to Choose Your Own Story and create a custom four pack of pints from the flavors below. Select your desired flavors from the drop down menu and add to cart.

  • Cookie au Lait: Coffee ice cream with Back To Nature sandwich creme cookies.
  • Ooey Gooey Butter Cake: the creamiest vanilla ice cream with hunks of St. Louis-style Ooey Gooey Butter Cake
  • Snap, Mallow, Pop!: rich marshmallow ice cream with baked rice crispie clusters
  • The Munchies: pretzel-infused ice cream with clusters of Ritz crackers, potato chips, pretzels and mini M&Ms
  • The Raw Deal: vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and pieces of brown butter cookie dough
  • Peppermint Pattie: peppermint ice cream with semi-sweet chocolate flakes and homemade dark chocolate covered peppermint patties
  • Strawberries & Cream: smooth strawberry ice cream made with organic strawberries
  • Nonna D’s Oatmeal Lace: brown sugar cinnamon ice cream with Nonna’s homemade oatmeal lace cookies
  • Butter Pecan Brittle: brown sugar ice cream with pieces of homemade pecan brittle
  • PB Wins the Cup: vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and and homemade peanut butter cups.
  • Sweet Cream & Cookies: sweet cream ice cream with pieces of all-natural Back to Nature sandwich creme cookies.
  • Oh, Fudge!: vegan / non-dairy chocolate made with coconut milk and a splash of rum.
  • Chocolate Milk & Cookies: chocolate milk ice cream with pieces of organic Back to Nature sandwich creme cookies
  • Coffee Toffee Coffee: coffee ice cream with housemade espresso-infused chocolate-covered toffee pieces.

      Every pint of Ample Hills ice cream is made at our shop in Gowanus, Brooklyn. We are a growing and evolving business, but we still make our ice cream the same way we did when we opened three years ago: pasteurizing on-site, making mix-ins from scratch, and challenging ourselves to make the next best flavor. We hand pack, sticker and stamp every package for delivery. We are a dedicated bunch of ice cream lovers, thrilled to be sharing our product with you.

      Shipping Information

      We are receiving a very high demand for our ice cream both in-store and for shipping nationwide. As a result, we need to limit the amount of ice cream that is sold online each day to ensure there is enough ice cream for everyone. The next available shipping day is preselected by default. You will receive your ice cream 1-2 days after your ship day, depending on shipping speed selected in checkout. You're welcome to choose a ship day in the future if desired.

      Shipping Pledge

      Everyone loves receiving the gift of ice cream at their doorstep but no one likes receiving melted ice cream. This is why we will happily reship your ice cream or issue you a full refund if it does not arrive perfect, delicious and frozen.